About This Item

Share This Item

The AAPG/Datapages Combined Publications Database

GCAGS Transactions

Abstract


Gulf Coast Association of Geological Societies Transactions
Vol. 22 (1972), Pages 253-255

Negative Evidence and Pleistocene History

W. F. Tanner (1)

ABSTRACT

Studies of Florida, the Yucatan, and other nearby coastal areas have shown that (outside of tectonically disturbed belts), there are no Pleistocene reefs more than 10 meters above present mean sea level. If interglacial times produced complete ice-cap melting, and a concomitant mean sea level rise, reef-building organisms should have flourished (a) sensibly farther north than now and (b) sensibly higher (above sea level) than now. This has not been found.

These studies have also shown that there are no obvious large pre-Sangamon coastal deposits (away from major deltas). If the Sangamon and the Holocene have been typical of Pleistocene interglacial times, then classical theory requires at least two more such deposits (Aftonian and Yarmouth). They either are not present, or if present are not nearly as extensive as Sangamon accumulations.

Further studies of these areas have shown that there are no high flights of Pleistocene marine terraces. Those terraces commonly mapped as Pleistocene, within the study area, are very low features of Sangamon and Holocene age, or are higher features of Pliocene and Miocene age, or cannot be dated.

Several conclusions follow:

  1. The cooling which brought on late Cenozoic ice ages must have occurred in the late Tertiary, rather than in the Quaternary.
  2. Melting of the full set of ice caps, during Quaternary time, was never complete (including now).
  3. Sea level, in Quaternary time, never stood much higher than it stands today.
  4. Aftonian and Yarmouth sea levels were (a) slightly lower than in Sangamon and Holocene time, or (b) did not maintain a position, similar to now, long enough for significant deposits to be made, or (c)maintained such a position for so long that almost all deposits were removed by erosion.
  5. The next long-term trend -- barring short-term fluctuations -- must be one of climatic cooling and a marked drop in mean sea level.

Pay-Per-View Purchase Options

The article is available through a document delivery service. Explain these Purchase Options.

Watermarked PDF Document: $14
Open PDF Document: $24